By: Julianne Mason, Restoration Program Coordinator
It’s an understatement to say that woody invasives are a major threat to our natural areas. They can displace native plant communities, alter wildlife habitat, and impact nutrient cycling and other ecosystem processes. Here in northeastern Illinois, they have become nearly ubiquitous. I’m hard pressed to think of any protected upland areas in my county that are not threatened by some kind of woody invasive species. The scale of where woody invasives need to be treated = basically, everywhere we want to maintain or restore highly diverse natural communities!

Dense brush before restoration (left) and more diverse savanna community after invasive shrubs are managed (right).
Previous posts in this blog have documented how basal bark treatments are an effective and efficient method to kill invasive woodies. Bill Kleiman’s original posts on the topic were published in five parts in 2016. Part 1, Part 2, Part 3, Part 4, Part 5. If you haven’t read them yet, I highly recommend doing so. Based on his recommendation and data, we did our own trials which were also highly successful. JM post. After that, we started using basal bark treatments fairly extensively to combat invasive woodies. Even so, we still use cut stump treatments in many situations too. I analyzed the past six years of treatment data to compare the time and resources needed for the two different treatment methods to control woody invasives.

Woodland where invasive shrubs have not been controlled (left) and where woodland has been managed with prescribed burning and basal bark treatment to invasive shrubs (right).
Here’s a summary of the past six years of treatment data for my organization (the Forest Preserve District of Will County in Illinois). For scale, we own ~22,000 acres in 80 preserves scattered across the county, and we perform a moderate level of ecological management in ~6,000 acres.
Cut stump treatments are when the invasive shrubs are physically cut, using chainsaws, hand tools, or specialized machinery like forestry mowers. Herbicide is typically applied to the cut stump to kill the shrub.

Cut stump treatment where the brush is cut with chainsaws (left) and herbicide applied to the cut stumps (right).
Sometimes, the cut material is stacked into piles and burned. This is fun and satisfying, and brush clearing using the cut/stack/burn method is a popular activity during volunteer workdays. The main advantage of cut stump treatments is instant gratification. We’re humans, after all, and it’s very satisfying to see visible progress after a day of hard work. A dense thicket of shrubs in the morning is physically removed, and it’s very satisfying to look back at our progress at the end of the day.

The cut/stack/burn approach is popular because it is fun and satisfying. We’re humans and we love instant gratification.
If machinery like a forestry mower is used, one drawback is that ground disturbance caused by the machinery can kill plant crowns located in the top inch of soil and result in opportunities for weedy species to establish. Generally, there is a slower recovery of the native plant community. This is especially true if the ground is not frozen solid. In our area, there are often limited numbers of days when the ground is frozen solid, which limits the acreage that can be treated under optimal ground conditions.

Mechanical clearing also results in instant gratification. Compare the area cleared (right) to the uncleared area of dense shrubs (back, left).
An unfortunate reality is that many invasive shrubs resprout vigorously after a cut stump treatment, and areas often need multiple re-treatments after the initially satisfying (but rather ineffective) cut stump treatment.

Invasive shrub resprouts after cut stump treatment. Note how much the shrubs grew back by the following summer.
In a previous study, I found that only ~30% of resprouting shrubs died from a follow-up foliar herbicide treatment. Insert sad face here.

Invasive shrub resprouts look dead after a foliar herbicide treatment (left). However, 70% of them rebounded to life (right).
Cut Stump Treatments – By the Numbers: Due to various factors, most of our cut stump treatments have been done by hand using chainsaws, and clearing with machinery has been used less frequently. For the past six years of available data (2017-2022), cut stump treatments have taken an average of 38 person-hours per acre. To complete 949 acres of cut stump treatments, it has taken over 30,000 hours by our staff, contractors, and volunteers. The initial cut stump treatments have used 1.0 gallon of herbicide per acre. Follow-up foliar treatments to re-sprouts have used an additional 1.8 gallons of herbicide per acre, and taken an additional 5 person-hours per acre. All that adds up to a lot of effort! However, multiple rounds of follow-up treatments are often needed, and in balance, little effective management is achieved especially compared with the amount of time and effort invested.
Basal bark treatments are an herbicide-only method. We typically use a backpack sprayer to spray the bottom part of the stem with 15% triclopyr ester (Garlon 4 or equivalent) in bark oil. It’s important to get full 360 degree coverage around the stem’s circumference for it to be effective. If most species are only sprayed on one side of them stem, the treatment will not fully kill them. A happy exception is that all canes that come out of the ground of multiflora rose and Japanese barberry need to be treated, but full 360 degree coverage is not necessary for those species. For small diameter shrubs, just the bottom inch or two need to be sprayed. For massively large shrubs (4-6+ inch diameter), the bottom 9-12” need to be sprayed. We try to use low pressure on the backpack sprayers to minimize the overspray zone and reduce collateral damage to other plants.

Basal bark herbicide crew (left) and invasive shrub with basal bark herbicide treatment (right).
The main downside of basal bark treatments is that it can take a long time (even 12-18 months) for treated woodies to die. However, it’s highly effective – more than 95% of properly treated individuals do die. Eventually. It just takes time. From an emotional standpoint, it’s the complete opposite of the instant gratification of cut stump treatments – the gratification is delayed by many months or even years.

Slow death. Invasive shrub still has green leaves 6 months after basal bark treatment (left), but is fully dead 12 months after treatment (right).
Basal Bark Treatments – By the Numbers: For the past six years of our data (2017-2022), basal bark treatments have taken an average of 4 person-hours per acre. A few of the very densest brush areas took more than 40 hours per acre, which is on par with most cut stump treatments. But those super-dense areas only accounted for 4% of treatment entries. In almost all cases, the brush looks scary from a distance and the edges can be dense. However, when you get in there, nearly all areas are actually passable to be treated with a backpack sprayer. Overall, basal bark treatments took significantly less time than cut stump treatments. Our staff, contractors, and volunteers have been able to treat 4,900 acres in less than 20,000 hours. An average of 1.7 gallons of herbicide was applied per acre during basal bark treatments, which is slightly more than the initial amount of herbicide applied during cut stump treatments (1.0 gal/ac) but less than initial cut stump treatments plus foliar resprout herbicide applications (2.8 gal/ac).
Cut Stump Treatments
Basal Bark Treatments
- Instant gratification
- Resource intensive – 43 hours/ acre by hand
- 2.8 gallons of herbicide per acre
- Ground disturbance potential if machinery
- Re-sprout lots
- Foliar follow-up – only 30% effective on resprouts
- Multiple years of follow-up needed
- Delayed gratification
- Resource efficient – 4 hours/ acres
- 1.7 gallons of herbicide per acres
- Up to 12-18 months for shrubs to die
- Dead standing
- >95% effective
- Patience needed
Given the scale of acreage that needs invasive woody treatments, we need to be able to treat thousands of acres per year effectively with our current resources. Like most natural resource management organizations, we have a limited amount of time, money, and personnel. Basal bark treatments take patience, but they are very efficient and effective. We need to recognize our human emotions, and to acknowledge that the biggest advantage of cut stump treatments is that they give us instant gratification. However, to manage the scale of the woody invasive threat, we need to have patience with basal bark treatments, a slower-acting but more effective management approach. It’s important to effectively scale up invasive woody treatments in order to maintain or restore highly diverse natural communities. Efficient, effective management (albeit with delayed gratification) is ultimately more satisfying!

* Special thanks to my co-worker, Becky Blankenship, for making the graphs!


































