Lesson learned: Better to have 5 fabulous acres than a 50 acre weed patch

Better to go slow enough to do the job well.  If you have enough seed to plant 15 acres you might be better to put that seed on 5.  Why?  Because planting too thin is a common cause of poor results. That five great acres can yield the seed to plant the next five and the next 50. Large prairie plantings thinly populated by native plants leads to weeds, work, and aggravation.

An example of well done: Volunteers Tom and Jenny Mitchell had 28 acres of former row crop ground to plant but did the job in four plantings of 7 acres each.  Below they stand in their very nice two year old prairie planting with 52 species planted at about 25 pounds per acre bulk weight. They restricted the species in the planting to those that occurred on the adjacent remnant prairie.  After two years they had 56 native plants, a native mean Conservatism of 4.4, and transect Floristic Quality Index of 26. If you don’t know what those values mean, the point is they got a lot of nice plants filling in what was a crop field.  The planting looks like a remnant prairie.   Now, after a decade has passed this planting is still looking very good.

Mitchells Jenny Tom IMG_1108_helzer

 

 

Posted in Uncategorized | 5 Comments

Lesson learned: Plant all species you want on year 100 on year 1

A generation ago it was said that to plant a prairie you start by planting a “matrix” of rough and tough native plants to make the soil ready for the more finicky plant species to be added years later.  These finicky, or conservative, species might be plants like birdsfoot violet, lead plant, pussytoes, shooting star, and many others.  The rough and tough might be plants like indian grass, bee balm, yellow coneflower, and big bluestem. 

We have found we can plant all species on year one.

Photo below is one of dozens of pasque flower on a gravelly prairie planting that have been doing well for a quarter century:

Pasque Flower (Anemone patens)

Birdsfoot violet on a remnant prairie. We find these come up in plantings too:

violets at coyote point

Rough blazing star on a remnant prairie. They come up thick in plantings:

blazing star

End.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | 3 Comments

Lesson learned: Plant a high diversity of seed by starting early

To create diverse prairie, you not only need a lot of seed weight per acre but you need a lot of different species of seed.  We start harvesting in May and go into November.

from PP planting

The photo above was taken in spring from a fine planting that was about ten years old.  The species seen here are usually left out of prairie plantings because their seed is ready to pick in early summer, before people traditionaly consider it time to harvest seed.  Shown are wood betony, two species of pussytoes, Bicknell’s sedge, Muhlenberg’s sedge, and an alumroot leaf in lower right.

jay in planting

The master of this planting is volunteer steward Jay Stacy.  He and friends harvested seed from 157 species.  A study transect done after a decade had 82 native species with only five non-native.   The floristic quality values mimic our better remnant prairies.  Other plants includes Spiranthes orchid, three species of violets, the rare prairie bushclover, and lots of lead plant and northern dropseed.

This planting and many others will be looked at during our annual GRN workshop, this year held at Nachusa Grasslands September 9-11, 2014.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | 2 Comments

Plant a large weight of seed

It takes a lot of seeds per acre to make sure an area fills in with native plants, not weeds.

IMG_3056 mixing seed

In the photo, around 3,000 pounds of hand collected seed is being mixed on the floor.   There is over 125 species in this dry-mesic seed mix.  Some of the barrels have just one species of seed. In a new planting that was a former row crop field, we are planting 40 to 60 pounds per acre.  We don’t clean our seed so perhaps 40% of that bulk weight is chaff.  The bottom line is this is a lot of seed per acre.

Further west of Nachusa, Chris Helzer in dry Nebraska is getting solid results using much less seed per acre on sandy soils.

When we look back on our past plantings we feel confident that poor plantings often resulted from “spreading our seed too thin”, the metaphor made real.

 

Posted in Uncategorized | 5 Comments

Lesson learned: Decide whether your prairie planting will be low or high diversity.

storm front over pale purple coneflower Nachusa by BKleiman 2013 06 22

This prairie planting created by volunteer steward, Bernie Buchholz and friends,  is very diverse with over 165 species of plants showing up after several years from 175 species planted.  Yes, there is an eye popping amount of pale purple coneflower and a storm front to capture the drama. 

Over the next several posts I will share lessons learned on prairie restoration.  The first lessons is to decide whether you want high or low diversity results. 

High diversity takes extra time and resources to produce. If your habitat restoration goal is short term like with a Conservation Reserve Program ten year contract, then simply plant some grasses and maybe a few forbs.  

If you want habitat for birds then you may not need a plethora of plant species.  But, if you want to mimic the diversity of remnant prairie on the assumption that good things will result, or to provide habitat for all sorts of insects, or you want to connect remnant prairies with restored prairies in between….then you are talking about high diversity, and my lessons learned are for you.

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

GRN workshop at Nachusa September 9-11, 2014

Save the date!

Nachusa Grasslands will host the next Grassland Restoration Network workshop on September 9, 10, and 11, 2014.

Registration will only be $50 to $75 and include most meals. Such a deal.

The target audience for the GRN workshop are people actively doing/directing high diversity prairie restoration at a significant scale; or doing the science. The workshop has a lot of field time with some inside talks. We talk a lot about techniques, equipment, monitoring and measuring success, the science behind the restoration, and other wonkish topics.

Nachusa Grasslands has over 110 prairie plantings and many nice remnant prairies for you to look at, with many restoration very well done. September is a nice time of year too. Nachusa Grasslands is two hours west of Chicago in Illinois. http://www.nachusagrasslands.org/

So put the date on your calendar, and budget enough money for registration, travel, and hotel. We will have more details at this site by May.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Which herbicide for various weeds

Lespedeza daurica IMG_3830 003

Above: An asian bushclover, Lespedeza daurica, speciman sits out to help people learn what this invasive weed looks like.  You can’t kill it with Transline/Stinger but triclopyr or Milestone does the job.

Every manager has their list of what weeds they have to control and what herbicides or techniques they use to control it.  The link below is my current list:

https://grasslandrestorationnetwork.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/which-herbicide-for-various-weeds-july-2013.pdf

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

2013 GRN Workshop Success

The 2013 GRN Workshop at Columbia Missouri was a fine success.   The main leaders of the workshop were Malissa Underwood, Elizabeth Middleton, Chris Newbold and Jeff Demand.  We also had registration assistance from Mindy Kremer of the Conservation Heritage Foundation, and logistical support from Corinne Carpenter of Mizzou.

IMG_2456

We had around 90 people join us at the University of Missouri in Columbia.  We had a day of good talks and then visited Tucker Prairie.  We also spent a day in the field hearing good stories about planting prairie at Prairie Fork Conservation Area.  It was good to hear ideas that make us think and see good works in progress.  Thank you to all that participated.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Sometimes we wait

By Bill Kleiman

Recently I wrote how it could be a good thing to use a tractor applied boom spray across a failed restoration to return it to grass. But there is the other way too, waiting. Fourteen years ago we sprayed glyphosate (Roundup) on a fallow cattle pasture that was mostly brome grass and a few weeds. We then seeded with a rich mix of prairie species, mowed it a few times that first year, and then did annual weed work on it year after year. The weed work was not hard, but there was always some to do, mostly sweet clover and parsnip. We saw some native plants established but we looked down on this planting for years because we mostly saw the silly yellow coneflower and bee balm which screams out “prairie planting”.

But slowly this restoration has spiraled upwards. I walked around for 15 minutes today and wrote down 37 native plants and 8 weeds and saw no invasive plants. It is good enough to keep adding seed to and keep up the hand weeding.  Here is a photo of a portion:

meiners uplands photo

Why keep this planting but boom spray another planting to grass only? If the planting is not a weed headache, a time sink, full of invasive legumes that can’t be controlled then using a boom spray may be the right path. Also,is the emerging plant community reasonably diverse and abundant? As with everything, there is no one answer.

Here are the plants I saw in that 15 minute walk with Bernie Buchholz:

SCIENTIFIC NAME COMMON NAME FAMILY
Achillea millefolium Yarrow Comp
Anemone cylindrica Thimbleweed Ranan
Apocynum cannabinum Dogbane (Indian Hemp) Apocy
Artemisia ludoviciana gnaphalodes White Sage; Prairie Sage Comp
Asclepias syriaca Common Milkweed Asclp
Asclepias tuberosa interior Butterfly Weed Asclp
Aster ericoides (prostratus) Heath Aster Comp
Astragalus canadensis Canadian Milk Vetch Legu
Baptisia leucantha White Wild Indigo Legu
Bromus inermus Smooth (Hungarian) Brome Grami
Carex bicknellii Copper-shouldered oval Sedge Cypera
Carex muhlenbergii (enervis) Sand Bracted Sedge  (Muhlenberg’s) Cypera
Cirsium discolor Pasture Thistle Comp
Convulvulus arvensis Field Bindweed Convo
Cornus racemosa Gray DoWilhelm Good Corna
Daucus carota Queen Anne’s Lace Umbel
Desmodium illinoense Ill. Tick Trefoil Legu
Echinacea pallida Pale Purple Coneflower Comp
Elymus canadensis Prairie Wild Rye Grami
Erigeron strigosus Daisy Fleabane Comp
Helianthus grosseserratus Sawtooth Sunflower Comp
Helianthus rigidus (laetiflorus) Prairie Sunflower Comp
Heliopsis helianthoides False Sunflower; ” Ox-eye “ Comp
Lespedeza capitata  — Round-headed Bush Clover Legu
Medicago lupulina Black Medic Legu
Mirabilis nyctaginea (oxybaphus) Four O’Clock Nycta
Monarda fistulosa Wild Bergamot Labia
Phleum pratense Timothy Grami
Poa compressa Canada Blue Grass Grami
Pycnanthemum tenuifolium Narrow-leaved Mountain Mint Labia
Ratibida pinnata Yellow  Coneflower Comp
Rhus glabra Smooth Sumac Anaca
Rubus allegheniensis Common Blackberry Rosac
Rudbeckia hirta Black-eyed Susan Comp
Rudbeckia subtomentosa Sweet Blackeyed Susan Comp
Silphium integrifolium Rosinweed Comp
Solidago canadensis Canada Goldenrod Comp
Solidago rigida Stiff Goldenrod Comp
Sorghastrum nutans Indian Grass Grami
Sporobolus asper Rough Dropseed Grami
Sporobolus heterolepis Prairie Dropseed Grami
Tradescantia ohiensis Ohio Spiderwort Comm
Trifolium pratense Red Clover Legu
Verbena stricta Hoary Vervain Verbe
Vitis riparia Wild (Riverbank) Grape Vitac
Zizia aurea Golden Alexanders Umbel
Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | 2 Comments

2013 GRN meeting Missouri: parking, map, directions

Parking information:

Designated visitor parking garage is the Virginia Avenue Parking Garage, labeled VAG on the Campus Map and is at the intersection of Lake and Hitt Streets.
Missouri University Parking Garage map: http://umcspace.missouri.edu/muparking/default.aspx

Buildings to know (Map labels):
MU STUDENT CENTER (location of Tues/Thurs meetings)
MEMORIAL UNION (location of Wed. evening dinner)
Missouri University Campus Map: http://map.missouri.edu/

Location of bus and van pick up/drop off:
Hampton Inn
3410 Clark Ln
Columbia, MO
https://maps.google.com/maps?q=Hampton+Inn+Clark+Lane+Columbia,+MO&hl=en&ll=38.962879,-92.287173&spn=0.017485,0.041585&sll=38.304661,-92.437099&sspn=4.516941,10.645752&hq=Hampton+Inn&hnear=Clark+Ln,+Columbia,+Missouri&t=m&z=15

Directions to Tucker Prairie (Tues p.m.):
Get off Interstate 70 at Exit 144 (Highway M). Head south on County Road 223 for 1.5 miles. Then head left (east) on County Road 220 for one mile. Then head left (north) on County Road 215 for 1.5 miles. The entrance is on the left side (west) of the road.
Directions to Prairie Fork (Wed field day):
1. Exit Interstate 70 at the Williamsburg Exit (Exit 161).
2. Take State Route D North into Williamsburg (0.4 miles) and follow Route D as it turns west (2.3 miles).
3. Route D will turn south and cross Interstate 70.
4. Stay on Route D for 1.9 miles.
5. The main entrance road into Prairie Fork will exit to the east off of Route D.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment